: RE: Caste-based Anti-Discrimination Legislation in the UK
From: Gurmit Singh [mailto:Gurmit@singh.net] 
Sent: Thursday, 11 April 2013 3:20 PM
To: 'Gurnam Singh'
 Dear Dr. Gurnam Singh Jee,  The Hon’ble Lord Singh and Veer Gurmukh Singh have provided valuable feedback. Due to considerable time variation, I could not view/ listen discussion as was informed by you. I shall be grateful if you could kindly again tell me how it could be heard through any Website or YouTube?
   With best wishes and Chahrdi Kalaa,
         Gurmit Singh (Australia

From: SIKHMESSENGER@aol.com [mailto:SIKHMESSENGER@aol.com] 
Sent: Thursday, 11 April 2013 9:04 PM
To: hsx035@coventry.ac.uk; Gurmit@singh.net

A DELIBERATE DISTORTION OF THE GURUS TEACHINGS
I am saddened and at a loss to understand why Dr Jasdev Singh Rai goes around trying to muddy the waters of clear Sikh teachings. I am even more saddened that some of our gurdwaras and Sikh television aid and abet him in this by giving him a platform to do so.
It has been some years since I was making real progress with Bernard Stassi the right hand man of President Chirac of France to secure an exemption from the then proposed banning of headgear in state schools. He was impressed with the sacrifice of Guru Teg Bahadhur in defending freedom of belief. He accepted my explanation that the Sikh turban was an essential part of Sikh identity and stood for a commitment to uphold freedom of belief, even for those who chose a secular path. Then Dr Rai appeared on the scene and argued that the turban was only a cultural head covering.
One can be charitable and argue that that he genuinely misunderstood the importance of a symbol of Sikh identity, but a few years later he caused further concern about his motives. It was at a function organised by the Department of Communities and Local Government for which we were asked to provide literature about the Sikh faith He declared his inability to do this because he had to get agreement of certain groups in India. On another occasion when a Sikh lady asked for non-halal food at a Basakhi function, Dr Rai advised her to be more accommodating.
On Wednesday night he was inexplicably provided a platform on Sikh TV to oppose government legislation banning discrimination on grounds of caste. He then launched into pseudo social science gibberish about ‘caste’ being an invention of the British. Has this learned doctor never read the Guru Granth Sahib written centuries before British arrival in India? Is he unaware of numerous gurbani quotations like ‘ask not a persons caste but look to the inner light within’, or the Guru reminding us that the evil of caste in Hindu society was so strong that even the shadow of a lower caste was said to pollute the food of a person of higher caste. 
Sikh teachings remind us about how we should treat others and condemn caste and other forms of discrimination. The law in Britain seeks to do the same and all who call themselves Sikhs should support it. Unfortunately, some naively argue that legislation is not necessary, and caste discrimination will go away simply by talking about it. Precisely the same arguments were used again and again against legislation to prohibit discrimination against colour or national origin but it continued unabated until the passing of the 1976 Race Relations Act.   
Sadly there are also some who call themselves Sikhs, who seek to preserve the remnants of caste that despite the Gurus teachings still linger in Sikh society. Jasvinder Singh Nagra, a close ally of Dr Rai, absurdly urges Sikhs to join a petition opposing the proposed law banning discrimination on grounds of caste because different jattis in Luton Gurdwara ‘get on with each other’.
We are now gearing up to the celebration of Baisakhi when Guru Gobind Singh finally freed Sikhs from the shackles of caste like distinctions. Shame on those who wish to hang on to them. To Dr Rai and his supporters I ask why?  To those who accept the message of Baisakhi I say beware of those who deliberately distort Sikh teachings.    
  Indarjit Singh
(Lord Singh of Wimbledon)