FW: Article on Operation Bluestar - Rebuttal !
From: Verpal Singh [mailto:verpalsingh@yahoo.com]
Sent: Saturday, 10 August 2013 9:36 AM
To: Arwinder Pal Singh; Mukhtiar Singh; hsdilgeer@yahoo.com; Gurmeet Singh Sydney; 'Dr. Iqbal Singh Dhillon'
Subject: Re: Article on Operation Bluestar - Rebuttal !
Waheguru ji ka Khalsa; Waheguru ji ki Fateh.
It is most unfortunate that some of us feel the need to attack Dr Dhillon (nay, "all the Sikh PhD holders") personally rather than engage on points raised by him (Dr Dhillon).
1. If we are seeking freedom for the community, then we have to first learn to respect each other's freedom to speak their mind without fear or favour. Ad hominem reasoning is not only counterproductive but cannot be described as walking the Guru's path - "I am not good, no one is bad."
2. Dr Dhillon has every right to say what he has. If this is the way we are going to behave in a sovereign Sikh State, how will our situation be any better than the one we are in today in India?
3. Guru Sahib did not wait to establish sovereignty before putting into practice his principles. He expected everyone who claimed to follow him, to practice his principles. Time and again I have come across so-called "Khalistanis" acting worst than an average human being. One such "Khalistani" in Auckland is currently awaiting trial on charges of trying to subvert the election process of New Zealand. His co-accused (in election case) and fellow "Khalistani" runs Indian grocery stores where he sells synthetic cannabis (legal under legal loopholes) - his clientele being overwhelmingly Sikh, we can imagine what sort of damage he is doing to the community here.
Please do consider whether we want to attain a sovereign state only to be enslaved by these sort of gentlemen who - a) on the lines of Pol Pot, condemn all educated people; b) abuse and intimidate someone who disagrees with them; c) subvert the election process to hijack people's right to elect their leaders; d) sell drugs to our youth in order to make a quick buck.
Would we want to live in a such a Sikh State? Or would we be paying agents to take us out of there so that "we may find a better life for our families" in USA or UK?
Kind regards,
Verpal Singh
Auckland
From: Arwinder Pal Singh <ranas001@hotmail.com>
To: Mukhtiar Singh <singh_m@hotmail.com>; "verpalsingh@yahoo.com" <verpalsingh@yahoo.com>; "hsdilgeer@yahoo.com" <hsdilgeer@yahoo.com>; Gurmeet Singh Sydney <gurmit@singh.net>; 'Dr. Iqbal Singh Dhillon' <drisdhillon@yahoo.com>
Sent: Saturday, August 10, 2013 9:58 AM
Subject: RE: Article on Operation Bluestar - Rebuttal !
Wonderful.. atlast someone has descried the Sikh phd holders in their true colors. educated in reductionist and empiricist education system these scholars utter and mutter knowledge based on facts whereas they lack a basic teaching of Guru Granth Sahib that dynamics of events is not to be seen with senses but as some higher dynamics producing these events as taught by German Historians like Von Humdlt. The study of historical facts is not done to fit the pieces together but to identify the processes working that are creating
those events.
If we truly bring the truth of Operation blue star out then we will need to hold Nuremberg Like Trials in which criminals will be Sikh PhD holders. For it is because of them that Sikh Intellectual Paradigm has been suppressed shackled crushed and common Sikhs struggles have become directionless and
fruitless whether it was Ghadar Movement, Akali Agitations Pre - 1947 or Post 1947.
With 1.2 Million Sikhs perished in last struggle its Sikh PhD holders who stand naked and intellectualy and morally bankrupt. And Giani Jarnail Singh and is group by sacrificing their lives are constantly beating the head of these dumb PhD holders with their shoes and will till eternity until their scholarship rise to match their sacrifices.
Any attempt to fully decode the True and Comprehensive Dynamics behind Operation blue star will require complete overthrow of this gang of vultures and chimpanzees feeding on the blood and flesh of common Sikhs.