Re: Article on Operation Bluestar-Rebuttal+
Sikh Sovereign State:Where and By whom ?!
From: HARDEV SINGH Virk [mailto:hardevsingh.virk@gmail.com] 
To: Arwinder Pal Singh
Dear All
The debate on the issue of a book by Dr IS Dhillon (Ex-Director Youth Welfare, PU Chandigarh) has become a mud-slinging match between Arwinder Singh and Verpal Singh. Perhaps, Gurmeet Singh Sydney kept me in this chain. My main objection is that debate has become too murky after fiery blasts of Arwinder Pal Singh.
He dares to call Doctorate degrees as Toilet Papers for the Sikhs;  rejects Sikh historians, except Sangat Singh, HS Dilgeer and Ajmer Singh; challenges Verpal Singh to show his papers on OBS, and what not.
 Personal Opinions of Scholars can differ on OBS, as it should be; Dr Dhillon has given his opinion, right or wrong.
In my opinion, Ganda Singh, JS Grewal, Khushwant Singh are better historians of Sikhs. They do not play with Sikh sentiments to promote themselves.  I was gifted the book of Dr. Sangat Singh by a friend. I was not impressed by his historical analysis. For example, he wants to create a link between Gangu Brahmin and Nehru family by his Strech of Imagination, like Bhai Santokh Singh, Author of Suraj Prakash Granth.
  My Opinion about Sant Jarnai Singh Bhindranwale: Jarnail Singh was a creation of Giani Zail Singh & Indra Gandhi to destroy Akali Dal. He fought Elections to SGPC on their bidding; failed miserably, went out of their control and started a Morcha, to counter Dharam Yudh morcha of Sant Longowal. Rest is part of OBS History now.
 I was asked to write Foreword of a book by Brig. OS Goraya, who was deputed as DC of Amritsar during OBS; it is an eye witness account but I wonder why no publisher has come forward to publish it. IMHO, it is an unbiased account of OBS operation by the army; role of Sikh Leaders, including Bhai Jarnail singh Jee.
 I do not want to enter into further discussion just to show my uppishness.
HS Virk
Ph.D. (Marie Curie University, Paris)

Subject: Re: Article on Operation Bluestar-Rebuttal+Sikh Sovereign State:Where and By whom ?!
 Dear Dr. Hardev Singh Virk,   Waheguru jee ka Khalsa  Waheguru jee kee Fateh
   I am extremely sorry for this futile discussion especially when the main issue has been side-tracked.
In fact, I had already closed this matter but no one listens. Earlier, S. Harbans Singh Aujla has also advised to discontinue. Hence, once again I request the active participants that if they have still any doubt, it is better to have dialogue one to one through their private Email Addresses because other persons are least interested for such personal vengeance or scoring more points. PLEASE STOP !Gurmit Singh

  B S Sidhu bssidhu73@gmail.com 
Satkarjog Gurmit singh Ji !! Ssa !! 
It's my humble request pls don't stop this discussion because its very much crucial for common Sikhs like me .. Hope our scholars have very good repute and they enjoying very good life .. That's also true when our sabit soorat Sikhs showing their position .. Common people from all communities are impressed .. But can u pls able to answer questions raised by Sar Arwinder Singh Randhawa .. He had awareness about guru sahib mission from his fore fathers who belong to baba Buddha Ji .. But he get real enlightenment after migrating in Australia... It's bad luck our elders after bhai mani singh and geyani Dit Singh not work very little on gurbani projection in population.. I'm happy Arwinder starts projection of gurbani which we missed in past manny years . 
He is young history and philosophy student who working tirelessly for humanity ... 
Dear Gurmit singh Ji pls don't  try to defuse the revolutionary fire pls ask him why he rejecting all theories ? I will assure you he have answer.. But he want people come forward and clear their position are they working for humanity or just for dahi pratha..
Regards 
Boota Singh